We want you to feel like family.

Don't take our word for it, here's what our guests have to say...

  • Booked a room at the hotel originally because the price was so fair! Little did I know upon arrival I was to be so well taken care of. I called ahead and asked for an early check in the girl was happy to oblige and was super friendly and courteous when I did show up. After checking in I had some questions they were again happy to help answer all these. The room was clean and neat. Bed was super comfortable (unlike most hotel beds I’ve experienced). I explored the hotel the next morning and found it to be beautiful, had an old time very homey feel. Met the soon to be owners whom made me feel... Read more...
  • Had a very nice experience at Fenway House on Thanksgiving day. I rented "The Venue" room for our family dinner so we could all sit down together without being crowded or having to balance plates on our laps. Catered in the turkey, ham and trimmings from Bender's Foods and potlucked the side dishes. The new owners, Parker and Jamie, were very friendly and helpful and the accommodations were excellent! Everyone had a relaxed and enjoyable dinner plus we were given a guided "historical" tour of the bar room and banquet room areas. We highly recommend it for small or large events. Fenway Hou... Read more...
  • Had the pleasure of meeting Parker and his family over the weekend while we were traveling through town for two nights. True gentleman that ensured an outstanding stay. He was able to work out the snags in our travel plans and render an accommodation that worked with those I was traveling with. Outstanding customer service. We will be returning again next year for our annual trip to an incredibly beautiful part of the midwest knowing that you can get five star service with a true small town personal touch at a great location.
  • Our class reunion was held in the bar area of the Fenway House. We rented the room and brought in our own food and drinks. We could not be happier with how the evening turned out! The staff was responsive to our needs, did everything to accommodate us, and even did some things above and beyond. Highly recommend! There is so much history with this particular building in Fennimore that it's really heart-warming to see owners and managers recognize that. They have just gotten started on this journey and we can't wait to see what's next for this business. The FHS Class of '84 wishes you noth... Read more...
Relax & enjoy your stay!

You can book your room online and stay with us in beautiful Fennimore, Wisconsin! We look forward to meeting you.

Get your perfect room before it's gone.
Scroll to Top